[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":422},["ShallowReactive",2],{"tool-security-entra-id":3,"footer-total":394,"related-security-entra-id":395},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"bestFor":7,"body":8,"category":351,"cons":352,"cover":357,"date":358,"description":359,"draft":360,"extension":361,"meta":362,"navigation":363,"notFor":364,"path":365,"pricing":366,"pros":371,"region":377,"score":378,"scoreBreakdown":379,"seo":384,"stem":385,"tags":386,"toolName":389,"updated":358,"url":391,"vendor":392,"__hash__":393},"tools\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fentra-id.md","Microsoft Entra ID 评测","元析评测","已经把邮箱、办公套件放在 Microsoft 365 上,想让登录与设备合规绑在一起的中大型企业",{"type":9,"value":10,"toc":323},"minimark",[11,15,23,26,29,45,48,52,55,58,61,64,67,70,73,76,79,82,85,88,92,95,99,102,106,109,113,116,120,123,126,129,207,210,286,292,296,300,303,307,310,314,317,320],[12,13,14],"h2",{"id":14},"结论先行",[16,17,18,22],"p",{},[19,20,21],"strong",{},"推荐,总分 8.4,免费档可用,P1 每人每月 $7、P2 每人每月 $10。"," 它最适合已经用 Microsoft 365 办公、终端由 Intune 管理的公司:员工用同一个账号进邮箱、进内网系统、进云主机,登录时顺带检查设备是否合规,策略在一个地方配完。",[16,24,25],{},"不适合的情形同样明确:如果公司没有微软订阅、应用全是自建或开源组件,Entra ID 的应用接入要靠逐个配 SAML,工作量比专业 IDaaS 大;而且国内主体与国际版目录彼此独立,跨境团队要提前规划。",[12,27,28],{"id":28},"这篇评测基于什么数据",[30,31,32,36,39,42],"ul",{},[33,34,35],"li",{},"官网定价页:2026-11 核对了微软 Entra 定价页面,确认 Free、P1(每人每月 $7.00)、P2(每人每月 $10.00)、Entra Suite(每人每月 $12.00)、Workload ID(每人每月 $3.00)的价目与主要包含项,均按年付费。",[33,37,38],{},"官方文档:查阅了 Microsoft Learn 上关于条件访问策略模板、身份保护风险检测、PIM 角色激活、访问评审、Entra Connect 同步方式的说明。",[33,40,41],{},"横向对照:与 Okta、Auth0 的公开价目和功能清单比对,重点看单点登录覆盖、策略引擎与开发者集成。",[33,43,44],{},"实测边界:未在统一环境下做十万级用户的登录压测;文中关于策略生效时延的描述来自官方文档与公开运维记录。",[12,46,47],{"id":47},"核心功能",[49,50,51],"h3",{"id":51},"条件访问与设备信任",[16,53,54],{},"条件访问是这套产品真正的核心。策略由\"谁、用什么设备、从哪来、访问哪个应用\"四个条件组合,再挂上允许、阻断或要求多因素认证的动作。常见的落地方式是把\"设备必须合规\"写进访问财务系统的策略里,员工用未加密的个人电脑登录时直接被拦。",[16,56,57],{},"策略引擎的优点是和终端管理同源:设备是否开启磁盘加密、系统补丁是否达标,这些状态由 Intune 上报,Entra 直接读。别家要做同样的事,通常得自己搭一套设备信任链。",[49,59,60],{"id":60},"混合身份与密码治理",[16,62,63],{},"本地域控与云目录之间靠 Entra Connect 同步,支持密码哈希同步、直通认证和联合认证三种模式。对还在用域控的企业,这一步决定了上线难度:密码哈希同步最省事,联合认证最灵活但也最脆弱。",[16,65,66],{},"自助密码重置在免费档就能用,回写到本地域控需要 P1。密码保护功能会拦截弱口令和公司名变体,这条策略对减少\"公司名 + 123\"这类口令很有效,配置只需要在门户里勾一次。",[49,68,69],{"id":69},"特权身份管理与访问评审",[16,71,72],{},"P2 里的 PIM 解决的是管理员权限长期在线的问题:全局管理员默认不持有权限,需要时申请激活,可以要求审批、限定小时数、强制多因素认证,到期自动收回。审计记录里能看到谁在什么时候激活了什么角色。",[16,74,75],{},"访问评审则按季度或半年发起一次,让业务负责人确认某个组的成员是否还该留着。这两项在等保和 ISO 审计里是高频检查项,自己做往往要拉表格,它把流程做成了产品功能。",[49,77,78],{"id":78},"外部协作与开发者集成",[16,80,81],{},"B2B 协作允许把外部邮箱作为来宾加入目录,再按组授权访问 Teams 频道或某个应用,每月 5 万 MAU 以内不额外计费。供应商、外包、并购过渡期的人员接入,用这套流程比发临时账号干净。",[16,83,84],{},"面向开发者的部分相对弱:应用注册、OIDC\u002FSAML 配置、Graph API 都在,但文档分散,自定义登录页面的能力有限,做面向消费者的注册登录不如 Auth0 顺手。",[12,86,87],{"id":87},"评分明细",[49,89,91],{"id":90},"功能完整度9210","功能完整度:9.2\u002F10",[16,93,94],{},"身份、设备、权限、治理四块齐全,能力深度在同类里靠前;面向消费者的登录体验不是它的强项。",[49,96,98],{"id":97},"易用性7610","易用性:7.6\u002F10",[16,100,101],{},"策略配置逻辑清楚但入口分散,管理员要在两个门户之间切换,新手容易配错范围。",[49,103,105],{"id":104},"数据质量9010","数据质量:9.0\u002F10",[16,107,108],{},"登录日志与审计日志字段完整,可导出到 Log Analytics 做关联分析,保留期随订阅变化。",[49,110,112],{"id":111},"性价比7810","性价比:7.8\u002F10",[16,114,115],{},"单看 P1 每人每月 $7 不算贵,但完整能力要 P2,叠加后人均成本上升。",[49,117,119],{"id":118},"客户支持8410","客户支持:8.4\u002F10",[16,121,122],{},"工单与文档体系成熟,中文文档齐全;严重故障的响应速度取决于订阅级别,标准支持不含 7×24 值守。",[12,124,125],{"id":125},"定价说明",[16,127,128],{},"它的价目表按\"身份能力\"分档,而不是按用户规模分档:同样一千人,只买 P1 和买到 P2,人均差 $3,年账单差 $36,000。很多公司最终按岗位混合授权——全员 P1,IT 与财务这些高权限岗位给 P2,这样既满足审计,又不用为前台接线员买身份保护。",[130,131,132,148],"table",{},[133,134,135],"thead",{},[136,137,138,142,145],"tr",{},[139,140,141],"th",{},"套餐",[139,143,144],{},"价格",[139,146,147],{},"说明",[149,150,151,163,174,185,196],"tbody",{},[136,152,153,157,160],{},[154,155,156],"td",{},"Free",[154,158,159],{},"$0",[154,161,162],{},"单点登录、基础多因素认证、自助改密,目录对象上限 50 万",[136,164,165,168,171],{},[154,166,167],{},"P1",[154,169,170],{},"$7.00\u002F用户\u002F月",[154,172,173],{},"加条件访问、回写、应用代理与组策略",[136,175,176,179,182],{},[154,177,178],{},"P2",[154,180,181],{},"$10.00\u002F用户\u002F月",[154,183,184],{},"加身份保护、PIM、访问评审与风险登录策略",[136,186,187,190,193],{},[154,188,189],{},"Entra Suite",[154,191,192],{},"$12.00\u002F用户\u002F月",[154,194,195],{},"叠加网络访问与私有访问组件",[136,197,198,201,204],{},[154,199,200],{},"Workload ID",[154,202,203],{},"$3.00\u002F用户\u002F月",[154,205,206],{},"面向服务主体与托管标识的授权",[12,208,209],{"id":209},"和竞品对比",[130,211,212,228],{},[133,213,214],{},[136,215,216,219,222,225],{},[139,217,218],{},"维度",[139,220,221],{},"Entra ID",[139,223,224],{},"Okta",[139,226,227],{},"Auth0",[149,229,230,244,258,272],{},[136,231,232,235,238,241],{},[154,233,234],{},"起价",[154,236,237],{},"$7\u002F用户\u002F月(P1)",[154,239,240],{},"SSO $2\u002F用户\u002F月起,年合同最低 $1,500",[154,242,243],{},"Essentials $35\u002F月,含 500 MAU",[136,245,246,249,252,255],{},[154,247,248],{},"策略引擎",[154,250,251],{},"条件访问,绑定设备合规",[154,253,254],{},"策略即代码,应用覆盖广",[154,256,257],{},"规则与 Actions 脚本",[136,259,260,263,266,269],{},[154,261,262],{},"应用接入",[154,264,265],{},"微软体系最顺,第三方需逐个配",[154,267,268],{},"预置连接器数量多",[154,270,271],{},"面向自建应用",[136,273,274,277,280,283],{},[154,275,276],{},"计费单位",[154,278,279],{},"按用户",[154,281,282],{},"按用户加模块",[154,284,285],{},"按 MAU",[16,287,288,291],{},[19,289,290],{},"怎么选",":员工都用 Microsoft 365,直接上 P1,先把条件访问和设备合规立起来;应用以 SaaS 为主、需要快速接几十个系统,Okta 的连接器省事;自己做产品要给外部用户登录,Auth0 的按 MAU 计费更贴合。",[12,293,295],{"id":294},"faq","FAQ",[49,297,299],{"id":298},"q-免费档够用吗","Q: 免费档够用吗?",[16,301,302],{},"A: 50 人以内、只用微软自家应用、只要求多因素认证,免费档确实够。一旦要做\"只允许公司电脑访问财务系统\"这种策略,就必须上 P1,因为条件访问在免费档里不可用。",[49,304,306],{"id":305},"q-p1-和-p2-的差别到底在哪","Q: P1 和 P2 的差别到底在哪?",[16,308,309],{},"A: 差在风险与治理。P1 能按条件拦人,P2 多了身份保护的风险检测、PIM 的按需激活和季度访问评审。要应付内审的权限定期复核,P2 基本躲不掉。",[49,311,313],{"id":312},"q-中国区-azure-和它有区别吗","Q: 中国区 Azure 和它有区别吗?",[16,315,316],{},"A: 有。由世纪互联运营的 Azure 中国是独立目录,和全球版 Entra ID 不互通,账号、应用注册、策略都要各配一套。跨境公司在两边都有业务时,通常要维护两套身份源,再靠同步工具人工对齐人员名单。",[12,318,319],{"id":319},"评测方法说明",[16,321,322],{},"元析评测围绕功能完整度、易用性、数据质量、性价比、客户支持五个维度打分,每项满分 10 分,权重相同。依据为官网定价页、Microsoft Learn 官方文档与公开版本说明,并与同类身份产品的公开价目对照;未做统一环境下的压测,涉及时延与容量的描述均标注了来源。",{"title":324,"searchDepth":325,"depth":325,"links":326},"",2,[327,328,329,336,343,344,345,350],{"id":14,"depth":325,"text":14},{"id":28,"depth":325,"text":28},{"id":47,"depth":325,"text":47,"children":330},[331,333,334,335],{"id":51,"depth":332,"text":51},3,{"id":60,"depth":332,"text":60},{"id":69,"depth":332,"text":69},{"id":78,"depth":332,"text":78},{"id":87,"depth":325,"text":87,"children":337},[338,339,340,341,342],{"id":90,"depth":332,"text":91},{"id":97,"depth":332,"text":98},{"id":104,"depth":332,"text":105},{"id":111,"depth":332,"text":112},{"id":118,"depth":332,"text":119},{"id":125,"depth":325,"text":125},{"id":209,"depth":325,"text":209},{"id":294,"depth":325,"text":295,"children":346},[347,348,349],{"id":298,"depth":332,"text":299},{"id":305,"depth":332,"text":306},{"id":312,"depth":332,"text":313},{"id":319,"depth":325,"text":319},"security",[353,354,355,356],"条件访问、身份保护、访问评审分散在三档订阅里,想凑齐一套完整能力往往要上 P2","管理门户层级深,同一项设置在 Entra 门户与 Microsoft 365 门户各有一处入口","国内使用走国际版节点,与世纪互联运营的 Azure 中国是两套独立目录,不能互通","非微软体系的应用接入仍需逐个配 SAML\u002FOIDC,应用库覆盖不如 Okta 广",null,"2026-11-16","Microsoft Entra ID 评测:免费档可管 50 万目录对象,P1 $7、P2 $10 每人每月(年付),条件访问与设备合规是核心;适合已用 Microsoft 365 的企业,自建应用接入不如专业 IDaaS 灵活。",false,"md",{},true,"技术栈以自建应用和开源组件为主、没有微软订阅的团队","\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fentra-id",{"free":363,"startingPrice":367,"currency":368,"billingPeriod":369,"notes":370},"7","USD","月","Entra ID Free 随 Azure 订阅提供;P1 每人每月 $7.00,P2 每人每月 $10.00,Entra Suite 每人每月 $12.00,Workload ID 每人每月 $3.00,均按年付费。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",[372,373,374,375,376],"免费档就能做单点登录与基础多因素认证,目录对象上限 50 万,中小企业够用","条件访问可按用户、设备合规状态、位置、应用敏感度组合策略,P1 起即可用","P2 含 Privileged Identity Management,管理员角色可设为按需激活并留审批记录","与 Microsoft 365、Azure、Intune 天然打通,设备合规状态直接作为访问条件","外部协作(B2B)在每月 5 万 MAU 以内不额外计费,供应商与外包接入成本低","global",8.4,{"features":380,"ease":381,"data":382,"price":383,"support":378},9.2,7.6,9,7.8,{"title":5,"description":359},"tools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fentra-id",[387,388,389,390],"网络安全","身份管理","Microsoft Entra ID","单点登录","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.microsoft.com\u002Fen-us\u002Fsecurity\u002Fbusiness\u002Fidentity-access\u002Fmicrosoft-entra-id","Microsoft","NMhwP-D_2bR2O7FxP7JPGRn2RHIyc0WFjVxPlYvQNKQ",1016,[396,405,414],{"path":397,"toolName":398,"description":399,"score":400,"pricing":401,"vendor":398,"date":404,"category":351},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002F1password","1Password","1Password 评测:个人年付 $2.99\u002F月起,双密钥加密机制与通行密钥支持扎实,适合重视跨设备凭证安全和员工权限回收的中小技术团队;不提供永久免费版,国内网络同步偶有延迟。",8.8,{"free":360,"startingPrice":402,"currency":368,"billingPeriod":369,"notes":403},"2.99","Individual 年付 $2.99\u002F月,Families 年付 $4.99\u002F月(含 5 人),Teams Starter Pack $19.95\u002F月(固定含 10 人),Business 年付 $7.99\u002F用户\u002F月。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页,均提供 14 天免费试用。","2026-09-26",{"path":406,"toolName":407,"description":408,"score":409,"pricing":410,"vendor":407,"date":358,"category":351},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fbitwarden","Bitwarden","Bitwarden 评测:免费版不限密码条目,个人 Premium 年付 $19.80(约 $1.65\u002F月),Teams 每用户每月 $4,服务端可自托管,适合预算有限的技术团队统一收口密码;审计报表与合规留痕比 Keeper 薄一层。",8.5,{"free":363,"startingPrice":411,"currency":368,"billingPeriod":412,"notes":413},"19.80","年","Free 档不限密码条数;Premium 年付 $19.80(约 $1.65\u002F月);Families 年付 $47.88(含 6 人);Teams 每用户每月 $4,Enterprise 每用户每月 $6,均按年付费。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",{"path":415,"toolName":416,"description":417,"score":409,"pricing":418,"vendor":421,"date":358,"category":351},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fcloudflare-waf","Cloudflare WAF","Cloudflare WAF 评测:Pro 套餐每年付 $20\u002F月即含托管规则与自定义规则,免费档只给基础防护,适合中小站点快速挡掉注入与扫描流量;规则调优深度与专属日志能力不如 Imperva 这类专业 WAF。",{"free":363,"startingPrice":419,"currency":368,"billingPeriod":369,"notes":420},"20","WAF 随套餐提供:Pro 年付 $20\u002F月(月付 $25),Business $200\u002F月起,Enterprise 按需报价;免费档仅含基础托管规则与有限自定义规则。Logpush 等日志外送能力需更高套餐或加购。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。","Cloudflare",1794788241422]