[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":442},["ShallowReactive",2],{"tool-security-aws-waf":3,"footer-total":416,"related-security-aws-waf":417},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"bestFor":7,"body":8,"category":373,"cons":374,"cover":379,"date":380,"description":381,"draft":382,"extension":383,"meta":384,"navigation":385,"notFor":386,"path":387,"pricing":388,"pros":393,"region":399,"score":400,"scoreBreakdown":401,"seo":407,"stem":408,"tags":409,"toolName":229,"updated":380,"url":413,"vendor":414,"__hash__":415},"tools\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Faws-waf.md","AWS WAF 评测","元析评测","业务已经跑在 AWS 上、用基础设施即代码管配置的研发与平台团队",{"type":9,"value":10,"toc":345},"minimark",[11,15,23,26,29,32,48,51,56,59,62,65,68,71,74,78,81,84,87,90,93,96,100,103,107,110,114,117,121,124,128,131,134,137,215,218,308,314,318,322,325,329,332,336,339,342],[12,13,14],"h2",{"id":14},"结论先行",[16,17,18,22],"p",{},[19,20,21],"strong",{},"推荐(限 AWS 用户),总分 8.1,每个 WebACL 每月 $5,每条规则每月 $1,请求每百万次 $0.60。"," 它适合业务已经在 AWS 上、配置用 Terraform 或 CloudFormation 管的团队:防护贴着 CloudFront 或负载均衡做,不用改域名解析,也不用维护额外一层代理。",[16,24,25],{},"不适合的情形:站点不在 AWS,或者团队里没人愿意读规则 JSON。这套东西的学习曲线比托管型 WAF 陡,规则写错导致的误杀要靠翻日志定位,没有可视化提示;小团队外包给安全服务商比自己配更划算。",[16,27,28],{},"按项目的经验,第一次上线至少预留两天:一天把托管规则跑成计数模式、看命中分布,一天把误杀样本挑出来加例外。跳过这一步直接切阻止,业务方当天就会来问为什么表单提交失败。",[12,30,31],{"id":31},"这篇评测基于什么数据",[33,34,35,39,42,45],"ul",{},[36,37,38],"li",{},"官网定价页:2026-11 核对了 aws.amazon.com\u002Fwaf\u002Fpricing,确认 WebACL($5\u002F月)、规则($1\u002F条\u002F月)、请求($0.60\u002F百万次)、Bot Control($10\u002F百万次)与 Shield Advanced($3,000\u002F月起)的价目结构。",[36,40,41],{},"官方文档:查阅了 AWS WAF 开发者指南中关于规则语句、WCU 容量、速率限制规则、托管规则组与日志配置的说明。",[36,43,44],{},"横向对照:与 Cloudflare WAF、Azure WAF 的计价与接入方式比对,重点看按量成本与配置门槛。",[36,46,47],{},"实测边界:未做统一环境下的攻击回放与误报率测试;文中拦截效果描述来自官方规则说明,成本估算基于公开价目。",[12,49,50],{"id":50},"核心功能",[52,53,55],"h3",{"id":54},"webacl-与规则模型","WebACL 与规则模型",[16,57,58],{},"WebACL 是一组有序规则的容器,每条规则由语句和动作组成:语句可以是 IP 匹配、字符串匹配、正则、地理限制、速率限制,或者引用另一个规则组;动作有允许、阻止、计数三种。规则按优先级从上到下匹配,第一条命中的规则生效。",[16,60,61],{},"这套模型的灵活度很高,但容量有限制:每条规则按复杂程度消耗 WCU,默认每个 WebACL 的容量上限是 1500 个 WCU,超了就得拆或者申请提额。写规则前先算容量,是这里的常识。",[52,63,64],{"id":64},"托管规则组与订阅",[16,66,67],{},"不想自己写规则,可以直接订阅托管规则组:AWS 自家的核心规则集、已知恶意输入规则集,以及 Marketplace 里第三方厂商的规则包。订阅后按月计费,规则内容由提供方更新,常见漏洞的虚拟补丁能跟上。",[16,69,70],{},"还有一点常被忽略:托管规则组只是\"能用\",不等于\"调好\"。默认动作往往是计数,要自己看一段时间日志再改成阻止,否则一上线就把正常业务拦了。",[16,72,73],{},"实际项目里更常见的问题是规则组之间的顺序:同一个请求可能同时命中\"SQL 注入\"和\"文件包含\"两条规则,先命中哪条决定了日志里记的是什么,也决定了例外该加在哪。AWS 把规则组内的语句拍平成按优先级执行的列表,调顺序要改 JSON,这一点比图形化产品费劲。",[52,75,77],{"id":76},"速率限制与-bot-控制","速率限制与 Bot 控制",[16,79,80],{},"速率限制规则按 5 分钟窗口统计来源 IP 的请求数,超过阈值后执行动作,常用于挡撞库和爬虫。阈值最低可设到每分钟几十次,配合作用域缩小到登录路径,效果比全站限速好。",[16,82,83],{},"Bot Control 是独立收费的能力,能识别常见爬虫、无头浏览器和自动化框架,支持按类别放行搜索引擎、拦截其余机器人。它对电商比价、票务抢购这类场景有用,单价也最高,上之前先估一遍请求量。",[52,85,86],{"id":86},"绑定方式与日志成本",[16,88,89],{},"它不改变流量路径:WebACL 关联到 CloudFront 分发、ALB、API Gateway 或 AppSync 后,请求先过规则再回源。对已经在用这些服务的团队,接入只是加一个关联动作,不需要改 DNS。",[16,91,92],{},"日志是另一笔账。请求日志可以写到 CloudWatch Logs、S3 或 Firehose,存储与查询按量收费,流量大的站点每月日志费可能超过 WAF 本身。常见做法是只记录拦截与计数的请求,把全量日志留给排查期。",[12,94,95],{"id":95},"评分明细",[52,97,99],{"id":98},"功能完整度8210","功能完整度:8.2\u002F10",[16,101,102],{},"规则类型齐全,托管规则组可订阅,缺内置的可视化调优界面。",[52,104,106],{"id":105},"易用性7410","易用性:7.4\u002F10",[16,108,109],{},"控制台配置步骤多,规则语句要手写 JSON 或 IaC,新人上手慢。",[52,111,113],{"id":112},"数据质量8510","数据质量:8.5\u002F10",[16,115,116],{},"日志字段完整,可落 S3 做长周期分析;查询需要自己写,开箱报表少。",[52,118,120],{"id":119},"性价比8010","性价比:8.0\u002F10",[16,122,123],{},"小流量站点月费很低,但 Bot Control 与日志费用叠加后总额可能翻几倍。",[52,125,127],{"id":126},"客户支持8310","客户支持:8.3\u002F10",[16,129,130],{},"文档详尽,支持计划分级;技术问题的响应速度取决于所购支持等级。",[12,132,133],{"id":133},"定价说明",[16,135,136],{},"三项基础费用里,规则费最容易失控:很多人把托管规则组、\"IP 例外\"、\"静态资源放行\"逐条拆开写,规则条数很快过百,每月光规则费就上百美元。省钱的做法是把能合并的条件写进一条规则,并定期清理已经失效的例外。",[138,139,140,156],"table",{},[141,142,143],"thead",{},[144,145,146,150,153],"tr",{},[147,148,149],"th",{},"项目",[147,151,152],{},"价格",[147,154,155],{},"说明",[157,158,159,171,182,193,204],"tbody",{},[144,160,161,165,168],{},[162,163,164],"td",{},"WebACL",[162,166,167],{},"$5\u002F个\u002F月",[162,169,170],{},"按容器计费,关联多个资源仍算一个",[144,172,173,176,179],{},[162,174,175],{},"规则",[162,177,178],{},"$1\u002F条\u002F月",[162,180,181],{},"托管规则组内规则按条计入",[144,183,184,187,190],{},[162,185,186],{},"请求",[162,188,189],{},"$0.60\u002F百万次",[162,191,192],{},"按经过 WAF 的请求量计费",[144,194,195,198,201],{},[162,196,197],{},"Bot Control",[162,199,200],{},"$10\u002F百万次",[162,202,203],{},"独立收费,可与基础规则叠加",[144,205,206,209,212],{},[162,207,208],{},"Shield Advanced",[162,210,211],{},"$3,000\u002F月起",[162,213,214],{},"含 DDoS 响应团队,需年度承诺",[12,216,217],{"id":217},"和竞品对比",[138,219,220,236],{},[141,221,222],{},[144,223,224,227,230,233],{},[147,225,226],{},"维度",[147,228,229],{},"AWS WAF",[147,231,232],{},"Cloudflare WAF",[147,234,235],{},"Azure WAF",[157,237,238,252,266,280,294],{},[144,239,240,243,246,249],{},[162,241,242],{},"计费",[162,244,245],{},"按 ACL、规则与请求量",[162,247,248],{},"按站点套餐",[162,250,251],{},"绑应用网关,按实例计费",[144,253,254,257,260,263],{},[162,255,256],{},"起价",[162,258,259],{},"$5\u002F月",[162,261,262],{},"$20\u002F月",[162,264,265],{},"随网关实例,门槛更高",[144,267,268,271,274,277],{},[162,269,270],{},"接入",[162,272,273],{},"关联云资源",[162,275,276],{},"改 DNS",[162,278,279],{},"绑网关或 Front Door",[144,281,282,285,288,291],{},[162,283,284],{},"调优体验",[162,286,287],{},"需写查询翻日志",[162,289,290],{},"控制台可视化",[162,292,293],{},"与 Azure 监控集成",[144,295,296,299,302,305],{},[162,297,298],{},"多云支持",[162,300,301],{},"仅 AWS",[162,303,304],{},"任意源站",[162,306,307],{},"仅 Azure",[16,309,310,313],{},[19,311,312],{},"怎么选",":业务在 AWS、配置走 IaC,选它最省心,成本也最低;站点跨云或有自建机房,Cloudflare 更合适;已经用 Azure 应用网关,直接用自带 WAF 少一层运维。",[12,315,317],{"id":316},"faq","FAQ",[52,319,321],{"id":320},"q-只开托管规则是不是就够了","Q: 只开托管规则是不是就够了?",[16,323,324],{},"A: 大多数站点够用,但要先把动作设为计数,观察一到两周的命中情况再切阻止。直接开阻止最常见的后果是老后台的表单提交被拦,业务方当天就会找上门。",[52,326,328],{"id":327},"q-费用到底怎么估","Q: 费用到底怎么估?",[16,330,331],{},"A: 按\"WebACL 数量 × $5 + 规则条数 × $1 + 请求量 × $0.60\u002F百万\"算,再叠加日志与 Bot Control。日请求百万级的站点,基础费用通常在几十美元量级,真正容易超预算的是日志存储。",[52,333,335],{"id":334},"q-能不能防-ddos","Q: 能不能防 DDoS?",[16,337,338],{},"A: 基础防护由 Shield Standard 免费提供,针对大流量攻击的清洗与响应团队要买 Shield Advanced,起步 $3,000\u002F月并需年度承诺。中小业务一般用 CloudFront 的吸收能力加 WAF 限速就够。",[12,340,341],{"id":341},"评测方法说明",[16,343,344],{},"元析评测围绕功能完整度、易用性、数据质量、性价比、客户支持五个维度打分,每项满分 10 分,权重相同。依据为官网定价页、AWS 官方开发者指南与公开配额说明,并与同类 WAF 的计价方式对照;未做统一环境下的攻击回放,成本数据按公开价目推算。",{"title":346,"searchDepth":347,"depth":347,"links":348},"",2,[349,350,351,358,365,366,367,372],{"id":14,"depth":347,"text":14},{"id":31,"depth":347,"text":31},{"id":50,"depth":347,"text":50,"children":352},[353,355,356,357],{"id":54,"depth":354,"text":55},3,{"id":64,"depth":354,"text":64},{"id":76,"depth":354,"text":77},{"id":86,"depth":354,"text":86},{"id":95,"depth":347,"text":95,"children":359},[360,361,362,363,364],{"id":98,"depth":354,"text":99},{"id":105,"depth":354,"text":106},{"id":112,"depth":354,"text":113},{"id":119,"depth":354,"text":120},{"id":126,"depth":354,"text":127},{"id":133,"depth":347,"text":133},{"id":217,"depth":347,"text":217},{"id":316,"depth":347,"text":317,"children":368},[369,370,371],{"id":320,"depth":354,"text":321},{"id":327,"depth":354,"text":328},{"id":334,"depth":354,"text":335},{"id":341,"depth":347,"text":341},"security",[375,376,377,378],"规则容量按 WCU 计算,复杂条件很快吃满配额,加规则要反复申请提额","没有可视化调优面板,查误杀要写查询语句翻日志,对非安全岗不友好","Bot Control 与 Fraud Control 单价高,流量大的站点这两项可能超过基础费用数倍","只服务 AWS 上的业务,多云或自建机房的站点用不上",null,"2026-11-16","AWS WAF 评测:每个 WebACL 每月 $5、每条规则 $1、每百万请求 $0.60,能贴到 CloudFront 与负载均衡上按量付费,适合业务已在 AWS 的团队;规则模型需要自己搭,控制台门槛比托管型 WAF 高。",false,"md",{},true,"站点不在 AWS、又没有专职云工程师的中小团队","\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Faws-waf",{"free":382,"startingPrice":389,"currency":390,"billingPeriod":391,"notes":392},"5","USD","月","每个 WebACL $5\u002F月,每条规则 $1\u002F月,请求按 $0.60\u002F百万次计费;Bot Control 另按 $10\u002F百万次,Shield Advanced 为 $3,000\u002F月起并需年度承诺;日志写入 CloudWatch 或 S3 另计。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",[394,395,396,397,398],"按 WebACL 与请求量计费,流量小的站点一个月可能只花几美元,不用买套餐","能直接挂在 CloudFront、ALB、API Gateway 与 AppSync 上,不必改 DNS 或加代理层","规则是声明式 JSON,和 Terraform、CloudFormation 一起管,变更可审可回滚","托管规则组可从 Marketplace 订阅,常见漏洞防护不必自己写","请求日志能落到 S3 或 Firehose,取证链路完整,便于做长周期分析","global",8.1,{"features":402,"ease":403,"data":404,"price":405,"support":406},8.2,7.4,8.5,8,8.3,{"title":5,"description":381},"tools\u002Fsecurity\u002Faws-waf",[410,411,229,412],"网络安全","WAF","云安全","https:\u002F\u002Faws.amazon.com\u002Fwaf\u002F","Amazon Web Services","W36y7Uy4vwo__ALpMC9RSp-0hyO3U3RqismPGP1X5Ok",1016,[418,427,435],{"path":419,"toolName":420,"description":421,"score":422,"pricing":423,"vendor":420,"date":426,"category":373},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002F1password","1Password","1Password 评测:个人年付 $2.99\u002F月起,双密钥加密机制与通行密钥支持扎实,适合重视跨设备凭证安全和员工权限回收的中小技术团队;不提供永久免费版,国内网络同步偶有延迟。",8.8,{"free":382,"startingPrice":424,"currency":390,"billingPeriod":391,"notes":425},"2.99","Individual 年付 $2.99\u002F月,Families 年付 $4.99\u002F月(含 5 人),Teams Starter Pack $19.95\u002F月(固定含 10 人),Business 年付 $7.99\u002F用户\u002F月。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页,均提供 14 天免费试用。","2026-09-26",{"path":428,"toolName":429,"description":430,"score":404,"pricing":431,"vendor":429,"date":380,"category":373},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fbitwarden","Bitwarden","Bitwarden 评测:免费版不限密码条目,个人 Premium 年付 $19.80(约 $1.65\u002F月),Teams 每用户每月 $4,服务端可自托管,适合预算有限的技术团队统一收口密码;审计报表与合规留痕比 Keeper 薄一层。",{"free":385,"startingPrice":432,"currency":390,"billingPeriod":433,"notes":434},"19.80","年","Free 档不限密码条数;Premium 年付 $19.80(约 $1.65\u002F月);Families 年付 $47.88(含 6 人);Teams 每用户每月 $4,Enterprise 每用户每月 $6,均按年付费。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",{"path":436,"toolName":232,"description":437,"score":404,"pricing":438,"vendor":441,"date":380,"category":373},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fcloudflare-waf","Cloudflare WAF 评测:Pro 套餐每年付 $20\u002F月即含托管规则与自定义规则,免费档只给基础防护,适合中小站点快速挡掉注入与扫描流量;规则调优深度与专属日志能力不如 Imperva 这类专业 WAF。",{"free":385,"startingPrice":439,"currency":390,"billingPeriod":391,"notes":440},"20","WAF 随套餐提供:Pro 年付 $20\u002F月(月付 $25),Business $200\u002F月起,Enterprise 按需报价;免费档仅含基础托管规则与有限自定义规则。Logpush 等日志外送能力需更高套餐或加购。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。","Cloudflare",1794788241149]