[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":410},["ShallowReactive",2],{"tool-security-authing":3,"footer-total":384,"related-security-authing":385},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"bestFor":7,"body":8,"category":343,"cons":344,"cover":349,"date":350,"description":351,"draft":352,"extension":353,"meta":354,"navigation":355,"notFor":356,"path":357,"pricing":358,"pros":363,"region":368,"score":369,"scoreBreakdown":370,"seo":375,"stem":376,"tags":377,"toolName":213,"updated":350,"url":381,"vendor":382,"__hash__":383},"tools\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthing.md","Authing 评测","元析评测","有开发能力、要做 SaaS 或移动应用账号体系的团队,尤其是需要微信、钉钉登录和快速上线的产品",{"type":9,"value":10,"toc":315},"minimark",[11,15,22,25,28,31,47,50,55,58,61,64,67,70,73,76,79,82,85,88,91,95,98,102,105,109,112,116,119,123,126,129,196,199,202,278,284,288,292,295,299,302,306,309,312],[12,13,14],"h2",{"id":14},"结论先行",[16,17,18],"p",{},[19,20,21],"strong",{},"推荐,总分 8.5。免费版覆盖 8,000 月活用户,基础版 139 元\u002F月起(含 1,000 活跃用户),适合有开发能力、要快速搭账号体系的 SaaS 团队。",[16,23,24],{},"Authing 卖的是\"别自己写登录\"。注册、登录、找回密码、第三方登录、多因素认证这些功能,自己实现一遍要两三个月,还容易在细节上出安全问题。它的组件嵌进去,一天能跑通主流程,后面按需加。",[16,26,27],{},"它的问题在合规深度。审计日志免费版只存 1 天,等保要求六个月留存的话,必须升到企业版,价格要单独谈。做 C 端产品、用户量大的团队,月活账单也会涨得比预期快。",[12,29,30],{"id":30},"这篇评测基于什么数据",[32,33,34,38,41,44],"ul",{},[35,36,37],"li",{},"官网定价页:2026-11 核对了 Authing 定价页的四个版本,确认月活档位、自建应用数、短信条数、审计日志留存与 SLA 条款。",[35,39,40],{},"官方文档:查阅了开发者文档里关于登录组件、SDK、OAuth\u002FOIDC 协议支持、多租户与权限模型的说明。",[35,42,43],{},"横向参照:与竹云科技的企业级 IAM、Okta 的 Workforce Identity 在用户规模与计费方式上做对照。",[35,45,46],{},"实测边界:注册了免费版账号,跑通了标准登录流程,未做万级并发的登录压测。文中关于接入耗时、性能的说法来自文档与公开资料。",[12,48,49],{"id":49},"核心功能",[51,52,54],"h3",{"id":53},"登录组件与多端-sdk","登录组件与多端 SDK",[16,56,57],{},"Authing 的核心是一个可嵌入的登录页:前端引入组件,配置好应用 ID,登录、注册、找回密码、验证码就都有了。样式可以改,也支持完全自定义 UI 后调 API。",[16,59,60],{},"SDK 覆盖 JavaScript、iOS、Android、Flutter、小程序等常用环境。社交登录是它的强项:微信、钉钉、企业微信、飞书这类国内渠道配好参数就能用,不用自己处理授权码换取和用户信息映射。",[51,62,63],{"id":63},"用户目录与多租户",[16,65,66],{},"用户、组织、角色、权限构成基本目录模型。支持用户扩展字段和自定义数据对象,业务侧的属性可以挂在用户上,不用另建表关联。",[16,68,69],{},"多租户是给 SaaS 厂商准备的:一套系统里给每个客户开一个租户,租户之间的用户和组织隔离,登录页可以按租户定制。这个能力在 B2B 产品里很实用,省掉自己实现租户隔离的工作量。",[51,71,72],{"id":72},"权限模型与数据资源授权",[16,74,75],{},"权限分两层:一层是角色和资源的功能权限,另一层是数据资源权限,细到某条数据能不能读。高级版起提供 1 个数据资源、100 个资源节点的额度,企业版可扩到 1,000 节点并支持加购。",[16,77,78],{},"复杂的授权逻辑靠自定义认证流程(Pipeline)实现:在登录或获取令牌的链路上插入自己写的代码,做风控判断、属性注入、外部系统校验。这个机制灵活,但也意味着复杂度转移到了开发侧。",[51,80,81],{"id":81},"安全能力与审计",[16,83,84],{},"支持多因素认证、登录防暴破、密码规则与轮换、自定义短信网关。审计日志记录登录、改密、权限变更等事件,留存时长按版本分档:免费 1 天、基础 3 天、高级 10 天、企业 30 天。",[16,86,87],{},"SLA 也按版本分:高级版 99.90%,企业版 99.99% 并承诺 1 小时内紧急响应。对普通业务够用,对金融类要求,这个分级要提前看清楚。",[12,89,90],{"id":90},"评分明细",[51,92,94],{"id":93},"功能完整度8310","功能完整度:8.3\u002F10",[16,96,97],{},"登录、注册、社交渠道、MFA、多租户、权限模型、审计都有,覆盖面比自建方案完整得多。扣分在高级授权:数据资源的细粒度控制额度小,超出要加钱。",[51,99,101],{"id":100},"易用性9010","易用性:9.0\u002F10",[16,103,104],{},"这是它最强的一项。文档结构清晰,示例代码能直接跑,控制台里创建应用、配回调地址、复制密钥三步就能联调。扣分在自定义认证流程:写 Pipeline 需要理解它的上下文对象,文档对这块的解释偏简略。",[51,106,108],{"id":107},"数据质量8210","数据质量:8.2\u002F10",[16,110,111],{},"用户数据、登录事件、权限变更有记录,字段够排查用。扣分在日志留存:免费和基础版的留存期太短,出了安全事件想回溯一周前的登录记录,只能靠企业版。",[51,113,115],{"id":114},"性价比8710","性价比:8.7\u002F10",[16,117,118],{},"免费版 8,000 月活对小产品够用很久,基础版 139 元\u002F月含 1,000 活跃用户,比自建的人力成本低。扣分在规模化:C 端用户到几十万月活时,账单会逼近甚至超过自建方案。",[51,120,122],{"id":121},"客户支持8310","客户支持:8.3\u002F10",[16,124,125],{},"文档和社区是主要支持渠道,工单响应按版本分级,高级版 24 小时内、企业版 2 小时内。扣分在电话支持:只有企业版配专属客户经理,中小客户基本靠工单和文档。",[12,127,128],{"id":128},"定价说明",[130,131,132,148],"table",{},[133,134,135],"thead",{},[136,137,138,142,145],"tr",{},[139,140,141],"th",{},"套餐",[139,143,144],{},"价格",[139,146,147],{},"说明",[149,150,151,163,174,185],"tbody",{},[136,152,153,157,160],{},[154,155,156],"td",{},"免费版",[154,158,159],{},"免费",[154,161,162],{},"8,000 月活用户、1 个自建应用、1 个社交账号连接、审计日志 1 天",[136,164,165,168,171],{},[154,166,167],{},"基础版",[154,169,170],{},"139 元\u002F月",[154,172,173],{},"1,000 活跃用户起、10 个自建应用、5 个工作流、300 条短信\u002F月、审计日志 3 天",[136,175,176,179,182],{},[154,177,178],{},"高级版",[154,180,181],{},"1,299 元\u002F月",[154,183,184],{},"20 个自建应用、10 个工作流、1,500 条短信\u002F月、MFA、自定义域名、99.90% SLA",[136,186,187,190,193],{},[154,188,189],{},"企业版",[154,191,192],{},"咨询销售",[154,194,195],{},"10,000 以上活跃用户、无限功能用量、99.99% SLA、1 小时响应、私有化可加购",[16,197,198],{},"价格核对说明:2026-11 核对官网定价页时,价格随活跃用户档位(1,000\u002F2,500\u002F5,000\u002F10,000)浮动,上表为基础档位。年付有折扣,具体比例以下单页为准。短信条数为套餐内额度,超出按条计费。",[12,200,201],{"id":201},"和竞品对比",[130,203,204,220],{},[133,205,206],{},[136,207,208,211,214,217],{},[139,209,210],{},"维度",[139,212,213],{},"Authing",[139,215,216],{},"竹云科技",[139,218,219],{},"Okta",[149,221,222,236,250,264],{},[136,223,224,227,230,233],{},[154,225,226],{},"形态",[154,228,229],{},"公有云 SaaS,私有化加购",[154,231,232],{},"私有化为主",[154,234,235],{},"公有云 SaaS",[136,237,238,241,244,247],{},[154,239,240],{},"起步价",[154,242,243],{},"139 元\u002F月(1,000 活跃用户)",[154,245,246],{},"项目报价",[154,248,249],{},"$2\u002F用户\u002F月起",[136,251,252,255,258,261],{},[154,253,254],{},"强项",[154,256,257],{},"接入快、社交登录全、按 MAU 计费",[154,259,260],{},"集团级目录与治理",[154,262,263],{},"应用集成数量多",[136,265,266,269,272,275],{},[154,267,268],{},"短板",[154,270,271],{},"审计留存短、大规模账单高",[154,273,274],{},"实施周期长",[154,276,277],{},"国内访问与中文支持弱",[16,279,280,283],{},[19,281,282],{},"怎么选",":产品要在一个月内上线、团队有前端开发,选 Authing;上万员工、要账号治理和权限回收,选竹云;海外业务为主、要和大量 SaaS 应用集成,选 Okta。",[12,285,287],{"id":286},"faq","FAQ",[51,289,291],{"id":290},"q-月活用户怎么算注册了不登录的人也要付费吗","Q: 月活用户怎么算,注册了不登录的人也要付费吗?",[16,293,294],{},"A: 不按注册数算,按当月有登录行为的去重用户数算。也就是说,注册了但一个月没登录的账号不计入。这个规则对\"C 端用户多、活跃比例低\"的产品友好,但要注意:通过 API 触发的用户信息查询也会计入活跃,具体口径以官网文档为准。",[51,296,298],{"id":297},"q-免费版能直接上生产环境吗","Q: 免费版能直接上生产环境吗?",[16,300,301],{},"A: 技术上可以,商业上有两个约束:免费版只有 1 个自建应用和 1 个社交账号连接,审计日志只留 1 天。如果产品只有一个应用、用户量在 8,000 月活以内,免费版跑一年没问题;但只要涉及付费用户或需要查历史登录记录,就该升基础版。",[51,303,305],{"id":304},"q-我们自己有开发团队为什么不用-keycloak-自建","Q: 我们自己有开发团队,为什么不用 Keycloak 自建?",[16,307,308],{},"A: 算三笔账:一是人力,Keycloak 部署容易,但要做中文登录页、微信登录、短信验证码、多租户,加起来是几个月的开发量;二是运维,身份系统挂了全站登不进,要有人值班;三是合规,审计日志、密码策略、漏洞跟进都要自己扛。月活十万以内,订阅成本通常低于自建的人力成本;再往上,自建开始划算。",[12,310,311],{"id":311},"评测方法说明",[16,313,314],{},"元析评测围绕功能完整度、易用性、数据质量、性价比、客户支持五个维度打分,每项满分 10 分,加权折算总分。本文价格与配额于 2026-11 对照 Authing 官网定价页核对,功能描述来自官方开发者文档。实际计费以官网结算页为准。",{"title":316,"searchDepth":317,"depth":317,"links":318},"",2,[319,320,321,328,335,336,337,342],{"id":14,"depth":317,"text":14},{"id":30,"depth":317,"text":30},{"id":49,"depth":317,"text":49,"children":322},[323,325,326,327],{"id":53,"depth":324,"text":54},3,{"id":63,"depth":324,"text":63},{"id":72,"depth":324,"text":72},{"id":81,"depth":324,"text":81},{"id":90,"depth":317,"text":90,"children":329},[330,331,332,333,334],{"id":93,"depth":324,"text":94},{"id":100,"depth":324,"text":101},{"id":107,"depth":324,"text":108},{"id":114,"depth":324,"text":115},{"id":121,"depth":324,"text":122},{"id":128,"depth":317,"text":128},{"id":201,"depth":317,"text":201},{"id":286,"depth":317,"text":287,"children":338},[339,340,341],{"id":290,"depth":324,"text":291},{"id":297,"depth":324,"text":298},{"id":304,"depth":324,"text":305},{"id":311,"depth":317,"text":311},"security",[345,346,347,348],"审计日志免费版只留 1 天、基础版 3 天、高级版 10 天,要 30 天才上企业版,合规场景卡得紧","数据资源权限这类细粒度授权只有高级版起步,复杂权限模型要自己写代码扩展","私有化部署只能加购,标准公有云版本的 SLA 到高级版才写 99.90%","C 端产品用户量大时,月活计费会迅速超过自建 Keycloak 的成本",null,"2026-11-16","Authing 评测:免费版支持 8,000 月活用户,基础版 139 元\u002F月含 10 个自建应用,登录组件和 SDK 接入快,适合 SaaS 与移动应用;审计日志免费版只留 1 天,企业级合规要上企业版。",false,"md",{},true,"员工上万、要走多级法人账号治理的集团,或者要求全内网私有化且预算有限的事业单位","\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthing",{"free":355,"startingPrice":359,"currency":360,"billingPeriod":361,"notes":362},"139","CNY","月","免费版 8,000 月活用户、1 个自建应用、1 个社交账号连接、审计日志存 1 天;基础版 139 元\u002F月(1,000 起,10 个自建应用、5 个工作流、300 条短信\u002F月);高级版 1,299 元\u002F月(20 个应用、MFA、自定义域名、99.90% SLA);企业版咨询销售,支持私有化加购。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",[364,365,366,367],"免费版给到 8,000 月活用户,小产品上线阶段基本不用付钱,试错成本低","登录组件和 SDK 覆盖 Web、移动端、小程序,接入一个标准登录页通常半天到一天","社交登录开箱可用,微信、钉钉、企业微信等国内渠道不需要自己写 OAuth 流程","只按活跃用户计费,不按注册用户或管理员席位收费,用户增长和账单增长对得上","cn",8.5,{"features":371,"ease":372,"data":373,"price":374,"support":371},8.3,9,8.2,8.7,{"title":5,"description":351},"tools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthing",[378,379,380,213],"网络安全","身份云","单点登录","https:\u002F\u002Fauthing.cn","北京蒸汽记忆科技有限公司","oQNZSQZDFW8IL0hUbnkCa-kDoZ--vTRHUJoe1MLP6F4",1016,[386,395,403],{"path":387,"toolName":388,"description":389,"score":390,"pricing":391,"vendor":394,"date":350,"category":343},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Faliyun-bastionhost","阿里云堡垒机","阿里云堡垒机评测:官网未直接挂牌,需在购买页按版本与资产数确认,包年包月。双因子、命令阻断、改密轮转与录播审计齐,等保三级材料好出;资产规模小的团队按档位买不划算,自定义脚本能力有限。",8.6,{"free":352,"startingPrice":316,"currency":360,"billingPeriod":392,"notes":393},"年","官网未公开报价,需联系销售,2026-11 核对。产品页规格区价格未展示,需在购买页按版本(基础版\u002F企业双擎版)、资产数、带宽与存储组合确认,包年包月为主,企业双擎版有 7 天试用。","阿里云",{"path":396,"toolName":397,"description":398,"score":390,"pricing":399,"vendor":394,"date":402,"category":343},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Faliyun-waf","阿里云WAF","阿里云WAF 评测:包年包月基础版 980 元\u002F月起,高级版 3,880 元\u002F月起,亦支持按量付费。与 ALB、CLB、CDN 一键引流免改 DNS,0day 虚拟补丁下发极快,适合主业务跑在阿里云上的团队;非阿里云源站或多云架构额外加购 QPS 与混合云节点后成本偏高。",{"free":352,"startingPrice":400,"currency":360,"billingPeriod":361,"notes":401},"980","支持按量付费与包年包月两种模式:包年包月基础版 980 元\u002F月起,高级版 3,880 元\u002F月起,企业版 11,300 元\u002F月起;按量付费按请求处理量 SeCU 与功能模块计费(提供小额免费试用额度)。价格于 2026-11 核对阿里云官网。","2026-09-29",{"path":404,"toolName":405,"description":406,"score":369,"pricing":407,"vendor":409,"date":350,"category":343},"\u002Ftools\u002Fsecurity\u002Fchaitin","长亭科技","长亭科技评测:雷池 WAF 社区版免费可自部署,商业版与洞鉴、牧云按项目询价。语义分析引擎误报低、Docker 与 K8s 部署顺手,适合有研发能力的互联网团队;缺硬件清洗能力,重保与等保材料要自己补。",{"free":355,"startingPrice":316,"currency":360,"billingPeriod":392,"notes":408},"雷池 WAF 社区版可免费下载自部署;专业版、企业版及洞鉴、牧云等产品官网未公开报价,需联系销售,2026-11 核对。商业版按防护节点数、域名与并发档位订阅。","北京长亭科技有限公司",1794788241133]