[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":405},["ShallowReactive",2],{"tool-legal-rmfyalk":3,"footer-total":377,"related-legal-rmfyalk":378},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"bestFor":7,"body":8,"category":335,"cons":336,"cover":342,"date":343,"description":344,"draft":345,"extension":346,"meta":347,"navigation":348,"notFor":349,"path":350,"pricing":351,"pros":355,"region":360,"score":361,"scoreBreakdown":362,"seo":368,"stem":369,"tags":370,"toolName":201,"updated":343,"url":374,"vendor":375,"__hash__":376},"tools\u002Ftools\u002Flegal\u002Frmfyalk.md","人民法院案例库 评测","元析评测","需要论证裁判规则、准备代理意见或答辩状的诉讼律师,以及做类案检索的企业法务",{"type":9,"value":10,"toc":307},"minimark",[11,15,23,26,29,48,51,55,58,61,64,67,70,73,76,79,82,85,88,91,95,98,102,105,109,112,116,119,123,126,129,184,187,190,264,270,274,278,281,285,288,292,295,298,301],[12,13,14],"h2",{"id":14},"结论先行",[16,17,18,22],"p",{},[19,20,21],"strong",{},"推荐,总分 8.6,免费,实名注册即可用。"," 它是诉讼律师做类案检索的第一站:案例由承办法官编写、最高法审核入库,每篇都有裁判要旨,论证路径是现成的。写代理意见时最费劲的\"同类案子法院怎么看\"这一步,在这里能省掉大半时间。",[16,24,25],{},"短板在量与检索。入库案例是精选,不是全量,冷门案由可能一篇都找不到;要穷尽某地某法院的全部判决,仍得回裁判文书网或商业库。把它当\"裁判规则库\"用,别当\"判决书全集\"用。",[12,27,28],{"id":28},"这篇评测基于什么数据",[30,31,32,36,39,42,45],"ul",{},[33,34,35],"li",{},"官网 rmfyalk.court.gov.cn 的注册、登录与检索流程,2026-11 实际走通一遍,含手机号实名环节",[33,37,38],{},"站内案例详情页的五段结构:入库编号、裁判要旨、基本案情、裁判理由、关联索引",[33,40,41],{},"官方上线信息:2024 年 2 月 27 日正式对社会开放,与法答网同批推进",[33,43,44],{},"与裁判文书网、北大法宝司法案例库在收录范围、检索字段、下载权限三项上的比对",[33,46,47],{},"我们没有做案例覆盖率的抽样统计,文中关于冷门案由收录情况的判断来自若干案由的实际查询",[12,49,50],{"id":50},"核心功能",[52,53,54],"h3",{"id":54},"裁判要旨先行",[16,56,57],{},"案例详情页最上面是裁判要旨,通常三五百字,把争议焦点和法院观点压成一段结论。往下才是基本案情、裁判理由。这个顺序对写文书的人很友好:先判断这篇案例能不能用,再决定要不要读完整说理。",[16,59,60],{},"要旨由承办法官提炼,不是机器摘要。它的措辞往往直接对应判决主文的论证逻辑,引用时不容易走偏。缺点是提炼者的取舍会影响你看到的重点,遇到复杂案件仍要读完整的裁判理由。",[52,62,63],{"id":63},"入库编号与关联索引",[16,65,66],{},"每篇案例有一个入库编号,由年份、案由代码、序号组成,类似\"2023-08-2-103-001\"这样的结构。编号一旦分配就不再变动,做类案台账时可以用它做唯一标识。",[16,68,69],{},"关联索引分两块:一块列出本案适用的法律条文,另一块列出同主题的其他入库案例。顺着索引走,能在十几分钟内把一个争议点的裁判脉络摸清。这是它比裁判文书网好用最明显的地方,后者只能靠关键词自己撞。",[52,71,72],{"id":72},"检索与筛选",[16,74,75],{},"检索框支持全文关键词,筛选项包括案由、关键词、审理法院、裁判年份、案例类型。案由用的是法院系统的标准分类,从刑事、民事、行政、国家赔偿到执行,一直下钻到三级案由。",[16,77,78],{},"实操上的建议是先按案由缩小,再用关键词搜争议点,最后按审理法院或年份排序。直接拿自然语言整句去搜,命中率会很低,因为它不做语义匹配,只认字面。",[52,80,81],{"id":81},"权限与使用限制",[16,83,84],{},"匿名状态只能看到标题和部分摘要,全文要注册。注册要手机号加实名信息,审核是自动的,一般当场通过。一个账号可以跨设备登录,但没有团队协作功能,所里几个人要各注册各的。",[16,86,87],{},"它不提供导出和 API。做类案检索报告,常见做法是把要旨和关联索引复制到 Word 里自己排版,或者截图存档。这一点和商业库差距明显,后者能一键生成带目录的检索报告。",[12,89,90],{"id":90},"评分明细",[52,92,94],{"id":93},"功能完整度8410","功能完整度:8.4\u002F10",[16,96,97],{},"要旨、案情、理由、索引四段结构齐全,检索字段够用,关联跳转做得扎实。扣分在没有导出、没有 API、没有统计分析和团队协作。",[52,99,101],{"id":100},"易用性8210","易用性:8.2\u002F10",[16,103,104],{},"界面比多数法院系统清爽,搜索框突出,详情页排版适合长文阅读。减分在必须注册才能读全文,以及案由选择需要一点专业判断。",[52,106,108],{"id":107},"数据质量9410","数据质量:9.4\u002F10",[16,110,111],{},"案例经审核入库,事实认定和说理经过把关,引用风险低。这是它最硬的地方。扣 0.6 分是因为收录量有限,且不同案由的入库密度很不均衡。",[52,113,115],{"id":114},"性价比9210","性价比:9.2\u002F10",[16,117,118],{},"免费,无广告,无推广位。对独立执业律师和小所来说,相当于白得一套裁判规则库,省下的商业库年费可以覆盖不少办案成本。",[52,120,122],{"id":121},"客户支持7410","客户支持:7.4\u002F10",[16,124,125],{},"有使用说明和常见问题,但入口不显眼,遇到检索异常没有在线客服,只能提交问题等回复。系统维护时段偶有登录失败,重试即可。",[12,127,128],{"id":128},"定价说明",[130,131,132,148],"table",{},[133,134,135],"thead",{},[136,137,138,142,145],"tr",{},[139,140,141],"th",{},"使用方式",[139,143,144],{},"价格",[139,146,147],{},"说明",[149,150,151,163,173],"tbody",{},[136,152,153,157,160],{},[154,155,156],"td",{},"公众查询",[154,158,159],{},"免费",[154,161,162],{},"匿名可看标题与摘要,全文需实名注册",[136,164,165,168,170],{},[154,166,167],{},"律师与法务使用",[154,169,159],{},[154,171,172],{},"与个人身份绑定,不按席位收费",[136,174,175,178,181],{},[154,176,177],{},"机构接入",[154,179,180],{},"不提供",[154,182,183],{},"官网无 API、无批量数据服务,也没有机构版",[16,185,186],{},"它的免费是彻底免费,没有\"基础版够用、核心功能要付费\"的设计。代价是没有服务承诺:系统升级、检索规则调整都不会提前通知,使用者只能自己适应。",[12,188,189],{"id":189},"和竞品对比",[130,191,192,208],{},[133,193,194],{},[136,195,196,199,202,205],{},[139,197,198],{},"维度",[139,200,201],{},"人民法院案例库",[139,203,204],{},"中国裁判文书网",[139,206,207],{},"北大法宝司法案例库",[149,209,210,224,236,250],{},[136,211,212,215,218,221],{},[154,213,214],{},"定位",[154,216,217],{},"精选裁判规则库",[154,219,220],{},"裁判文书公开平台",[154,222,223],{},"综合案例检索库",[136,225,226,229,231,233],{},[154,227,228],{},"起步价",[154,230,159],{},[154,232,159],{},[154,234,235],{},"需联系销售,按账号与子库报价",[136,237,238,241,244,247],{},[154,239,240],{},"优势",[154,242,243],{},"要旨现成、关联索引清楚、说理集中",[154,245,246],{},"文书量最大、覆盖法院最全",[154,248,249],{},"检索字段多、可批量导出、带引证码",[136,251,252,255,258,261],{},[154,253,254],{},"短板",[154,256,257],{},"总量小、需实名、无导出",[154,259,260],{},"检索粗糙、近年公开量收缩",[154,262,263],{},"报价不透明、年费高",[16,265,266,269],{},[19,267,268],{},"怎么选",":要论证某个争议点法院怎么看,先来这里,要旨能直接用;要确认某个法院、某个法官的全部判决,回裁判文书网;要做批量检索报告、需要引证码和导出,北大法宝仍不可替代。",[12,271,273],{"id":272},"faq","FAQ",[52,275,277],{"id":276},"q-不注册能看案例全文吗","Q: 不注册能看案例全文吗?",[16,279,280],{},"A: 不能。匿名只能看到案例标题、案由和部分要旨,点开全文会跳转到登录页。注册需要手机号和实名信息,一般当场通过,不收费。所里多人使用要各自注册,没有共享账号。",[52,282,284],{"id":283},"q-案例库和裁判文书网到底是什么关系重复吗","Q: 案例库和裁判文书网到底是什么关系,重复吗?",[16,286,287],{},"A: 定位不同。裁判文书网是文书公开平台,量大但质量参差;案例库是最高法审核后的精选,收录有门槛,说理经过整理。同一案件可能两边都有,案例库那版读起来更省力。近两年文书网公开量收缩,案例库的参考价值反而更突出。",[52,289,291],{"id":290},"q-为什么我按案由搜出来的案例很少","Q: 为什么我按案由搜出来的案例很少?",[16,293,294],{},"A: 三个原因。入库总量本来就有限,冷门案由可能只有几篇;案由选得太细,三级案由下常常是空的,退到二级再搜;关键词写成了口语,它只做字面匹配。把案由放宽、关键词换成判决书里的固定表述,结果通常能多出几倍。",[12,296,297],{"id":297},"评测方法说明",[16,299,300],{},"元析评测围绕功能完整度、易用性、数据质量、性价比、客户支持五个核心维度打分,每项满分 10 分,加权折算总分。文中对注册流程、详情页结构、检索字段的描述,均于 2026-11 在该站实际操作核对;案例收录量与案由分布未做抽样统计。",[16,302,303,306],{},[19,304,305],{},"最后更新",":2026-11-16",{"title":308,"searchDepth":309,"depth":309,"links":310},"",2,[311,312,313,320,327,328,329,334],{"id":14,"depth":309,"text":14},{"id":28,"depth":309,"text":28},{"id":50,"depth":309,"text":50,"children":314},[315,317,318,319],{"id":54,"depth":316,"text":54},3,{"id":63,"depth":316,"text":63},{"id":72,"depth":316,"text":72},{"id":81,"depth":316,"text":81},{"id":90,"depth":309,"text":90,"children":321},[322,323,324,325,326],{"id":93,"depth":316,"text":94},{"id":100,"depth":316,"text":101},{"id":107,"depth":316,"text":108},{"id":114,"depth":316,"text":115},{"id":121,"depth":316,"text":122},{"id":128,"depth":309,"text":128},{"id":189,"depth":309,"text":189},{"id":272,"depth":309,"text":273,"children":330},[331,332,333],{"id":276,"depth":316,"text":277},{"id":283,"depth":316,"text":284},{"id":290,"depth":316,"text":291},{"id":297,"depth":309,"text":297},"legal",[337,338,339,340,341],"入库案例是精选,总量远小于裁判文书网,冷门案由可能一篇都没有","必须实名注册并登录才能看全文,匿名浏览只能看到标题和要旨摘要","不提供裁判文书全文的批量下载,也不给 API,做类案报告要一篇篇复制","检索不支持语义联想,案由选错就搜不到,新入行的律师容易在筛选条件上卡住","没有胜诉率、赔偿金额分布这类统计分析功能",null,"2026-11-16","人民法院案例库评测:最高人民法院主办,免费,需实名注册后查看全文。收录指导性案例与参考案例,每篇带裁判要旨和关联索引。总分 8.6,适合律师找类案说理;案例总量小,替代不了裁判文书网。",false,"md",{},true,"要穷尽某个法院全部判决、需要按当事人和金额批量筛查的案件调查场景","\u002Ftools\u002Flegal\u002Frmfyalk",{"free":348,"startingPrice":308,"currency":352,"billingPeriod":353,"notes":354},"CNY","年","公众查询免费,需手机号实名注册后登录查看案例全文;不设付费套餐,无机构版报价。2024 年 2 月 27 日上线。核对时间为 2026-11。",[356,357,358,359],"案例经法官编写、最高法审核后入库,同一案由下能直接读到本院倾向,说理比判决书原文更集中","每篇带入库编号、裁判要旨、基本案情、裁判理由、关联索引五段结构,写代理意见时可以整段借用论证顺序","关联索引把适用法条和同类案例串起来,从一篇案例能顺着跳到三五篇相关案例","免费开放,无广告、无推广位,检索结果里不会混进律所软文","cn",8.6,{"features":363,"ease":364,"data":365,"price":366,"support":367},8.4,8.2,9.4,9.2,7.4,{"title":5,"description":344},"tools\u002Flegal\u002Frmfyalk",[371,372,201,373],"法律与合规","案例检索","免费工具","https:\u002F\u002Frmfyalk.court.gov.cn","最高人民法院","3NN3beTzAw9CwnpMe9WHWaRFJ_6YQ0fnMTe1mazd7UU",1016,[379,387,396],{"path":380,"toolName":381,"description":382,"score":383,"pricing":384,"vendor":381,"date":386,"category":335},"\u002Ftools\u002Flegal\u002Fpkulaw","北大法宝","北大法宝 评测:报价不公开、需联系销售,法规与案例的引证码和时效标注最细,写文书引用绕不开。总分 8.9,适合律所、法务和需要精确引用的研究者,个人低频使用不划算。",8.9,{"free":345,"startingPrice":308,"currency":352,"billingPeriod":353,"notes":385},"官网未公开标准报价,需联系销售。公开入口只有申请试用与咨询,个人版、机构版、专题库分别报价,2026-11 核对时未找到价格页。","2026-09-11",{"path":388,"toolName":389,"description":390,"score":391,"pricing":392,"vendor":389,"date":395,"category":335},"\u002Ftools\u002Flegal\u002Fesign","e签宝","e签宝 评测:签署流量包 100 份 650 元、2000 份 10000 元,量大单价降到 5 元一份,按份买比按版本买灵活;但版本权益要询价。总分 8.7,适合合同量大、想按用量控成本的公司。",8.7,{"free":345,"startingPrice":393,"currency":352,"billingPeriod":353,"notes":394},"650","签署流量包 100 份 650 元、500 份 3000 元、1000 份 5500 元、2000 份 10000 元,有效期一年,折算 5 到 6.5 元一份。版本订阅与私有化部署官网未公开标准报价,需联系销售,2026-11 核对。","2026-09-15",{"path":397,"toolName":398,"description":399,"score":400,"pricing":401,"vendor":398,"date":404,"category":335},"\u002Ftools\u002Flegal\u002Ffadada","法大大","法大大 评测:基础版 350 元含 40 份签署、598 元含 80 份,价格在电子签里算低的;企业四档版本要询价,对接 API 得升到高阶。总分 8.5,适合几十人规模、合同量不大的公司。",8.5,{"free":345,"startingPrice":402,"currency":352,"billingPeriod":353,"notes":403},"350","基础版 350 元含 40 份签署、598 元含 80 份,来自官网首页公示;价格页对企业四档统一写「请联系商务经理」,下单前需确认适用身份。份数有效期以订单页为准,个人与企业身份权益不互通,2026-11 核对。","2026-09-29",1794788236319]