[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":425},["ShallowReactive",2],{"tool-collaboration-smartsheet":3,"footer-total":398,"related-collaboration-smartsheet":399},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"bestFor":7,"body":8,"category":356,"cons":357,"cover":363,"date":364,"description":365,"draft":366,"extension":367,"meta":368,"navigation":369,"notFor":370,"path":371,"pricing":372,"pros":377,"region":383,"score":384,"scoreBreakdown":385,"seo":391,"stem":392,"tags":393,"toolName":206,"updated":364,"url":396,"vendor":206,"__hash__":397},"tools\u002Ftools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fsmartsheet.md","Smartsheet 评测","元析评测","20 人以上、设有专职 PMO 或项目协调人的团队,需要甘特图、依赖链、审批签字和跨项目报表放在一处",{"type":9,"value":10,"toc":328},"minimark",[11,15,23,26,29,32,35,51,54,58,61,65,68,72,75,79,82,85,89,92,96,99,103,106,110,113,117,120,123,189,192,195,285,291,295,299,302,306,309,313,316,319,322],[12,13,14],"h2",{"id":14},"结论先行",[16,17,18,22],"p",{},[19,20,21],"strong",{},"推荐,总分 8.2,Pro 年付 $9\u002F成员\u002F月(月付 $12),贡献者免费。"," 它适合 20 人以上、设有专职 PMO 或项目协调人的团队,把甘特图、依赖链、审批签字和跨项目报表放在一处;想要数据库式关联、自己拖一个内部应用的轻量运营团队,选 Airtable 更顺手。",[16,24,25],{},"Smartsheet 的起点是一张电子表格,但行可以折叠成层级,列可以写成依赖,表头切一下就是甘特图。这个设计让懂 Excel 的项目经理第一天就能上手,不需要理解「卡片」「泳道」这些新概念。差别在依赖关系:给任务填上前置任务,改一次日期,后续节点会按关系自己顺延。",[16,27,28],{},"它的另一条腿是流程。审批请求发出后,收件人不需要账号,在邮件里点通过或驳回,结果写回指定单元格;更新请求可以只让对方填三个字段,不暴露整张表。这类动作在 Pro 档就能配,不用额外买模块。",[16,30,31],{},"代价是学习曲线和价格结构。界面偏表格,新手容易把层级和公式搞混;Pro 档每月 250 次自动化,项目一多就紧张;想用 Control Center 批量管项目,得进 Enterprise 档,而那一档不公开报价。",[12,33,34],{"id":34},"这篇评测基于什么数据",[36,37,38,42,45,48],"ul",{},[39,40,41],"li",{},"官网定价页:2026-11 核对 Pro 与 Business 两档的成员单价、成员数下限、自动化次数与免费贡献者规则,确认年付与月付差额为 $3 与 $5。",[39,43,44],{},"官方帮助中心:查阅依赖关系、基线、关键路径、审批请求、更新请求、报表与仪表盘、Control Center 相关条目,确认功能归属档位。",[39,46,47],{},"第三方资料:参考了 2026 年 Gartner 协作式工作管理魔力象限的公开信息,核对产品在组合管理与治理方向上的定位。",[39,49,50],{},"边界声明:没有在五千行以上的多项目工作区做并发加载实测,文中关于大表滚动卡顿、自动化排队的内容来自官方限额与用户社区讨论。",[12,52,53],{"id":53},"核心功能",[55,56,57],"h3",{"id":57},"表格抬头就是甘特图",[16,59,60],{},"一个工作表可以切成网格、甘特、卡片、日历四种视图,数据同源。甘特视图里,行与行之间的前置后继关系用箭头画出,拖动任务条改工期,下游节点按依赖自动移动。基线功能保存计划快照,实际进度与原计划并排显示,延期几天一眼能看出来。关键路径高亮标出,不必手工推算哪个节点最不能拖。",[55,62,64],{"id":63},"自动化审批与更新请求","自动化、审批与更新请求",[16,66,67],{},"自动化编辑器按「触发—条件—动作」三段配置,触发源包括行新增、字段变更、日期到达、表单提交。动作里有发提醒、请求审批、发起更新请求、移动行到另一张表、调用 webhook。审批与更新请求的好处是外部人员不占席位:供应商收到邮件,点开是一个只含几个字段的页面,填完写回原表。Pro 档每月 250 次自动化运行,Business 档放宽。",[55,69,71],{"id":70},"报表仪表盘与跨项目汇总","报表、仪表盘与跨项目汇总",[16,73,74],{},"报表把多张工作表的数据按条件合并,可以按负责人、状态、月份分组,只读展示给管理层。仪表盘把报表变成图表、指标卡和筛选器,一张页面看十几个项目的进度、预算消耗与风险数量。项目组合视图把多个项目的甘特叠在一条时间轴上,能看出同一批人是否被排到同一周。",[55,76,78],{"id":77},"control-center-与规模化治理","Control Center 与规模化治理",[16,80,81],{},"Control Center 面向 PMO:把一套项目模板(结构、公式、权限、报表)固化成蓝图,新项目立项时批量生成工作区,再把各项目的汇总数据回收到组合层。权限体系分账号级、工作区级、表级、行级四层,行级共享可以只给某一行打开发权限。这部分能力大多锁在 Enterprise 档。",[12,83,84],{"id":84},"评分明细",[55,86,88],{"id":87},"功能完整度8710","功能完整度:8.7\u002F10",[16,90,91],{},"甘特依赖、基线、关键路径、审批、更新请求、跨项目报表、组合管理都在,项目管理链条完整。扣分在于文档协作与即时沟通较弱,要靠外部工具补。",[55,93,95],{"id":94},"易用性7710","易用性:7.7\u002F10",[16,97,98],{},"对 Excel 熟手友好,公式与层级复用已有习惯。但界面信息密度高,新手要花时间理解层级缩进与依赖列的关系,培训成本高于看板类产品。",[55,100,102],{"id":101},"数据质量8110","数据质量:8.1\u002F10",[16,104,105],{},"同一份数据支撑多视图与报表,改一处全处更新,审批结果直接写回单元格,减少了手工转录。跨表引用多了以后,公式排查比较费劲。",[55,107,109],{"id":108},"性价比7910","性价比:7.9\u002F10",[16,111,112],{},"Pro 年付 $9 一个成员,10 人团队一年约 $1080,贡献者免费让外部协作成本很低。但自动化次数与高级治理能力按档位切得很硬,规模上去后单价跳到 $19 甚至询价。",[55,114,116],{"id":115},"客户支持8310","客户支持:8.3\u002F10",[16,118,119],{},"帮助中心文章细,模板与培训课程多,英文社区活跃。付费档有工单与电话支持,响应按档位分级;中文支持有限,国内团队遇到紧急问题通常要等一个工作日。",[12,121,122],{"id":122},"定价说明",[124,125,126,142],"table",{},[127,128,129],"thead",{},[130,131,132,136,139],"tr",{},[133,134,135],"th",{},"套餐",[133,137,138],{},"价格",[133,140,141],{},"说明",[143,144,145,157,168,179],"tbody",{},[130,146,147,151,154],{},[148,149,150],"td",{},"Pro",[148,152,153],{},"$9\u002F成员\u002F月(年付),月付 $12",[148,155,156],{},"1-10 名成员,贡献者免费不限量,含甘特、卡片、日历视图与每月 250 次自动化",[130,158,159,162,165],{},[148,160,161],{},"Business",[148,163,164],{},"$19\u002F成员\u002F月(年付),月付 $24",[148,166,167],{},"3 名成员起,访客与贡献者免费不限量,自动化额度更高,加品牌与目录管理",[130,169,170,173,176],{},[148,171,172],{},"Enterprise",[148,174,175],{},"联系销售询价",[148,177,178],{},"含 Control Center、行级权限、单点登录、审计与专属支持",[130,180,181,184,186],{},[148,182,183],{},"Advanced Work Management",[148,185,175],{},[148,187,188],{},"在 Enterprise 之上叠加组合管理、资源管理与 Bridge 集成",[16,190,191],{},"Pro 的成员数上限是 10 人,团队长到 11 人就必须换 Business,单价从 $9 跳到 $19,预算要提前留出空间。贡献者免费是压成本的核心:只填表、只回复更新请求的人不算成员。",[12,193,194],{"id":194},"和竞品对比",[124,196,197,213],{},[127,198,199],{},[130,200,201,204,207,210],{},[133,202,203],{},"维度",[133,205,206],{},"Smartsheet",[133,208,209],{},"Airtable",[133,211,212],{},"monday.com",[143,214,215,229,243,257,271],{},[130,216,217,220,223,226],{},[148,218,219],{},"定位",[148,221,222],{},"表格型项目管理与组合治理",[148,224,225],{},"表格型轻应用搭建",[148,227,228],{},"可视化工作流与看板",[130,230,231,234,237,240],{},[148,232,233],{},"起步价",[148,235,236],{},"Pro $9\u002F成员\u002F月(年付)",[148,238,239],{},"免费,Team $20\u002F席位\u002F月",[148,241,242],{},"Basic $9\u002F席位\u002F月(年付)",[130,244,245,248,251,254],{},[148,246,247],{},"甘特与依赖",[148,249,250],{},"原生依赖链、基线、关键路径",[148,252,253],{},"时间线视图,无依赖计算",[148,255,256],{},"甘特视图,依赖需较高档位",[130,258,259,262,265,268],{},[148,260,261],{},"强项",[148,263,264],{},"审批留痕、跨项目报表、Control Center",[148,266,267],{},"视图灵活、Interfaces 搭界面",[148,269,270],{},"界面直观、自动化模板多",[130,272,273,276,279,282],{},[148,274,275],{},"短板",[148,277,278],{},"学习曲线陡、界面密度高",[148,280,281],{},"无原生甘特、记录上限阶梯陡",[148,283,284],{},"复杂依赖与资源排期偏弱",[16,286,287,290],{},[19,288,289],{},"怎么选",":项目要交付给客户、每个节点要签字留痕、管理层要看组合进度,选 Smartsheet;运营想自己搭一个带表单的台账,选 Airtable;团队更看重界面直观、上手快,选 monday.com。三个都能做项目管理,区别在于你更怕审批丢证据,还是更怕同事不肯学。",[12,292,294],{"id":293},"faq","FAQ",[55,296,298],{"id":297},"q-贡献者免费把供应商拉进来协作有什么坑","Q: 贡献者免费,把供应商拉进来协作有什么坑?",[16,300,301],{},"A: 贡献者能看被共享的行、能回复更新请求、能上传附件,但不能新建表或改结构,对供应商刚好够用。坑在权限:共享时别整表放开,用行级共享或更新请求只给需要的几行,否则对方能看到同表里其他项目的信息。",[55,303,305],{"id":304},"q-pro-每月-250-次自动化30-人的项目够用吗","Q: Pro 每月 250 次自动化,30 人的项目够用吗?",[16,307,308],{},"A: 悬。如果每个任务节点都挂提醒,250 次大约只够七八条流程跑一个月。省额度的做法是把提醒合并成每日一次汇总,用报表代替逐行通知,审批只留在关键节点。真不够就换 Business。",[55,310,312],{"id":311},"q-从-excel-或-project-迁过来复杂依赖会不会乱","Q: 从 Excel 或 Project 迁过来,复杂依赖会不会乱?",[16,314,315],{},"A: 一次导入超过几百行、依赖超过三层时,建议先只迁结构和关键节点,别把历史任务全搬。Smartsheet 的依赖不允许成环,导入成环的数据会报错;",[12,317,318],{"id":318},"评测方法说明",[16,320,321],{},"元析评测围绕功能完整度、易用性、数据质量、性价比、客户支持五个维度打分,每项满分 10 分,加权折算总分。文中价格、成员数下限与自动化额度于 2026-11 对照 Smartsheet 官网定价页与帮助中心核实,Enterprise 档以销售报价为准。",[16,323,324,327],{},[19,325,326],{},"最后更新",":2026-11-16",{"title":329,"searchDepth":330,"depth":330,"links":331},"",2,[332,333,334,341,348,349,350,355],{"id":14,"depth":330,"text":14},{"id":34,"depth":330,"text":34},{"id":53,"depth":330,"text":53,"children":335},[336,338,339,340],{"id":57,"depth":337,"text":57},3,{"id":63,"depth":337,"text":64},{"id":70,"depth":337,"text":71},{"id":77,"depth":337,"text":78},{"id":84,"depth":330,"text":84,"children":342},[343,344,345,346,347],{"id":87,"depth":337,"text":88},{"id":94,"depth":337,"text":95},{"id":101,"depth":337,"text":102},{"id":108,"depth":337,"text":109},{"id":115,"depth":337,"text":116},{"id":122,"depth":330,"text":122},{"id":194,"depth":330,"text":194},{"id":293,"depth":330,"text":294,"children":351},[352,353,354],{"id":297,"depth":337,"text":298},{"id":304,"depth":337,"text":305},{"id":311,"depth":337,"text":312},{"id":318,"depth":330,"text":318},"collaboration",[358,359,360,361,362],"界面底色还是表格,新手第一天容易把行、层级和公式混在一起,培训成本高于看板类工具","组织层级、权限继承、共享规则分散在几处,管理员配错了很难排查,大账号需要专人维护","Pro 档只有每月 250 次自动化,30 人以上项目如果每个节点都挂提醒,很快会用完","Control Center、Bridge 等组合管理与集成能力锁在 Enterprise 档,报价不公开,预算不好提前算","国内访问速度一般,帮助中心与客服以英文为主,时差导致紧急问题当天难有回应",null,"2026-11-16","Smartsheet 评测:Pro 年付 $9\u002F成员\u002F月(月付 $12),贡献者与访客免费,甘特图、依赖链和审批流是长项,适合 20 人以上有 PMO 的项目团队;界面偏表格、学习成本高,轻量运营团队会觉得笨重。",false,"md",{},true,"不到 10 人的轻量运营团队,只想搭个带表单和自动提醒的台账,不需要关键路径与审批留痕","\u002Ftools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fsmartsheet",{"free":366,"startingPrice":373,"currency":374,"billingPeriod":375,"notes":376},"9","USD","月","套餐与价格:Pro $9\u002F成员\u002F月(年付),月付 $12,1-10 名成员,贡献者免费不限量,每月 250 次自动化;Business $19\u002F成员\u002F月(年付),月付 $24,3 名成员起,访客与贡献者免费不限量;Enterprise 与 Advanced Work Management 需联系销售报价。价格于 2026-11 核对官网定价页。",[378,379,380,381,382],"表格抬头就是甘特图,任务的前置后继关系直接写在行里,改一个日期,整条依赖链与后续节点自动顺延","自动化动作覆盖审批请求、更新请求、提醒与跨表复制,Pro 档每月 250 次,业务侧不用等开发排期","一个工作表能挂多份报表与仪表盘,跨十几个项目的进度、预算、风险可以合并成一张管理层视图","贡献者(Contributor)与访客不占付费席位,供应商、客户、外包可以只填指定单元格,席位数只算真正的项目成员","Control Center 支持按模板批量生成项目工作区,新项目立项时一次性铺好结构、权限与报表","global",8.2,{"features":386,"ease":387,"data":388,"price":389,"support":390},8.7,7.7,8.1,7.9,8.3,{"title":5,"description":365},"tools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fsmartsheet",[394,395,206],"办公协作","项目管理","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.smartsheet.com","iiHksjVoBzAS5kzPfW-GMreq-VXYVRtqDQ5woIGedUo",1016,[400,409,417],{"path":401,"toolName":402,"description":403,"score":404,"pricing":405,"vendor":402,"date":408,"category":356},"\u002Ftools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fnotion","Notion","Notion 评测:个人免费,团队Plus版年付$10\u002F席位\u002F月起,块编辑器、关系型数据库与Wiki知识库自由度极高;适合出海团队、独立开发者与远程协作小团队,不适合需要国内低延迟访问、本地考勤打卡与严格字段级权限的传统中大型企业。",8.6,{"free":369,"startingPrice":406,"currency":374,"billingPeriod":375,"notes":407},"10","Free版个人免费,但邀请第2名工作区正式成员后即受限于1000个Block(内容块)试用上限;Plus版年付$10\u002F席位\u002F月(月付$12),Business版年付$15\u002F席位\u002F月(月付$18),Enterprise版联系销售询价;Notion AI需额外加购($8-$10\u002F席位\u002F月)。价格于2026-11核对Notion官网。","2026-09-08",{"path":410,"toolName":411,"description":412,"score":404,"pricing":413,"vendor":416,"date":364,"category":356},"\u002Ftools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fslack","Slack","Slack 评测:免费版 $0,Pro $7.25\u002F人\u002F月(年付),Business+ $15\u002F人\u002F月。频道与 2600+ 应用集成最顺,适合已在用海外 SaaS 的跨部门团队;短板是免费版只留 90 天消息、国内直连不稳。",{"free":369,"startingPrice":414,"currency":374,"billingPeriod":375,"notes":415},"7.25","套餐与价格:Free $0(90 天消息历史、最多 10 个应用);Pro $8.75\u002F人\u002F月(按月付)或 $7.25\u002F人\u002F月(年付);Business+ $18\u002F人\u002F月(按月付)或 $15\u002F人\u002F月(年付);Enterprise+ 需联系销售。价格于 2026-11 核对官网 Pricing 页。","Salesforce",{"path":418,"toolName":419,"description":420,"score":421,"pricing":422,"vendor":419,"date":364,"category":356},"\u002Ftools\u002Fcollaboration\u002Fasana","Asana","Asana 评测:免费版 10 人内可用,Starter $10.99\u002F人\u002F月(年付)起,Advanced $24.99。任务依赖与跨项目视图清晰,适合市场、运营团队;短板是目标与工时能力锁在 Advanced。",8.4,{"free":369,"startingPrice":423,"currency":374,"billingPeriod":375,"notes":424},"10.99","套餐与价格:Personal(免费)最多 10 人;Starter $10.99\u002F人\u002F月(年付)、$13.49(按月);Advanced $24.99\u002F人\u002F月(年付)、$30.49(按月);Enterprise 需联系销售。Starter 与 Advanced 均标注附带 AI 能力,但请求额度按人每月计算。价格于 2026-11 核对官网 Pricing 页。",1794788221264]